23 Oct Maple Peanut Butter Toffee Cookies

Maple Peanut Butter Toffee Cookies // butterlustblog.comMaple Peanut Butter Toffee Cookies // butterlustblog.com

A few weeks ago, just days before my birthday (!!!), I received the most epic of epic packages in the mail. The kind of package that makes you first, do giddy little dances around your kitchen second, post dreamy pictures to your Instagram account, and third, open all five flavors and conduct a taste test by unashamedly dunking your finger into each. Yep, I’m talking about peanut butter.

FIVE KINDS. (The Bees Knees. Cinnamon Raisin Swirl. Dark Chocolate Dreams. White Chocolate Wonderful. Mighy Maple.)

Some women like ribbon-tied blue boxes filled with shiny things. Me? I like ugly brown boxes filled to the brim with peanut butter. Ok, that’s definitely mostly a lie. We’ll call it a tie, for these cookies’ (and Steve’s wallet’s) sake.

As much as I wanted to go all peanut butter monster and hide behind my untouched winter coats in the darkest corner of my closet with my box and a sleeve of Ritz Crackers, my food-blogger conscience got the best of me because, after all, peanut butter is for sharing. Or so say my skinny jeans.

Maple Peanut Butter Toffee Cookies // butterlustblog.comMaple Peanut Butter Toffee Cookies // butterlustblog.comMaple Peanut Butter Toffee Cookies // butterlustblog.com

Maple is definitely my favorite flavor this fall, so not surprisingly, the Mighty Maple flavor was a huge stand out for me. Pumpkin, of course, reigns king of all fall confections, but maple is not to be ignored. And the more I dream about scarves, apple picking, and living in a red & golden autumn wonderland (because dreaming is all I can do, forecast says 92F this weekend – ugh) the more I want to smother everything in maple.

The inspiration for these cookies (as if I needed more) came from a local Austin cookie company, Tiff’s Treats. They bake up the best damn cookies you ever had, then deliver them to your door while they’re still warm. Don’t even get me started, it should be illegal. I’ve spent more time than I’m willing to admit scouring the internet for their recipe secrets with zero success. A few weeks ago a couple dozen were delivered to my office for a coworker’s birthday, aaand since warm cookies are the crack cocaine of the workplace, I indulged. I grabbed what I thought was a peanut butter cookie only to have my tastebuds completely blown away by what was actually their flavor of the week – Maple Toffee. Seriously, why don’t I think of these things?

So these cookies happened, and I’m kind of a copycat. But I added peanut butter, so there.

Maple Peanut Butter Toffee Cookies // butterlustblog.comMaple Peanut Butter Toffee Cookies // butterlustblog.com

These Maple Peanut Butter Toffee Cookies flirt with the line between chewy and crispy. Bake them for just the right amount of time and you achieve a perfect balance between the two. You know, if you’re into that kind of thing. Brown sugar exclusivity not only enhances the chewy texture, but also adds an extra layer of warmth to the already cozy, autumnal notes from the maple. And the toffee bits? Not to be forgotten. We’re folding them in and sprinkling them on top to elevate these guys to next level cookie badass-ness. When baked, the toffee forms little melty pockets that are chewy (sensing a theme here), caramel-y, and oh my gawd irresistable.

Here’s a good place to note that the peanut butter used in this recipe was provided courtesy of  Peanut Butter & Co. This is not a sponsored post, so while I did not pay for the product, I also was not required to tell you guys about it…I just really, really like their peanut butter.  The brand is widely available — I know they sell it at most markets around me — so should the spirit move you, getcha’ some!

A Few Notes About This Recipe

I used Peanut Butter & Co.’s Mighty Maple flavored peanut butter in this recipe, but you can sub plain peanut butter if needed. I would recommend increasing the maple extract by 1/2 to 1 teaspoon if going this route. 

I used half light brown sugar, half dark brown sugar in this recipe because I didn’t want the molasses to conflict with all the other flavors in these cookies, but I don’t think that it made much of a difference — use whatever you have on hand!

While I do think natural maple syrup for flavor is the best, I chose to use maple extract in the recipe instead because substituting syrup for brown sugar would have affected the texture of the cookie. BUT if you try with syrup, let me know how they turn out! 

Enjoy! XO, Katie

Maple Peanut Butter Toffee Cookies


  • 1 cup all purpose flour
  • 3/4 tsp salt
  • 3/4 tsp baking soda
  • 1/2 cup unsalted butter, melted and cooled slightly
  • 3/4 cup maple flavored peanut butter (see notes)
  • 1/2 cup dark brown sugar
  • 1/2 cup light brown sugar
  • 1 egg
  • 1 tbsp maple extract
  • 3/4 cups toffee pieces, plus more for sprinkling


  • Melt your butter and set aside to cool for a few minutes. While it is cooling combine flour, baking soda and salt in a bowl and give them a good whisk to combine.
  • In the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with paddle attachment (or with a handheld mixer) beat together the butter and brown sugars until well combined. Add the peanut butter and continue to beat until smooth, about 1-2 minutes.
  • Add in the egg and the maple extract and mix until thoroughly combined. With the mixer on low, slowly add the flour mixture, mixing until just combined. Fold in the toffee pieces then cover and refrigerate for 30 minutes.
  • While your dough is chilling preheat your oven to 350F and line baking sheets with parchment paper.
  • When ready to bake, scoop about 2 tbsp of dough -- I like to use a cookie scoop to make sure all cookie portions are equal -- then roll into a ball and place on your lined cookie sheet. Flatten each ball slightly with your fingertips and then sprinkle with toffee bits.
  • Bake cookies at 350F for about 13-14 minutes for a more chewy cookie or 15-16 minutes for a crispier cookie. Remove from oven and cool on baking sheet for about 5 minutes then transfer to a wire cooling rack to finish cooling.
  • Ashley
    Posted at 10:22h, 23 October Reply

    I love PB& Co! The Cinnamon Raisin is my fave, though I’ve been wanting to try The Heat is On – it’s intriguing and I love spice! So cool you had a birthday preset from them!

    And the flavors in these cookies! Yes, please! Maple (I’m addicted) + toffee (who couldn’t be addicted) + maple PB? Seriously, why hasn’t someone thought of these earlier!? Love your blog!

    • KWahlman
      Posted at 10:36h, 23 October Reply

      Thank you, Ashley! The Heat is On?! I haven’t heard of that one but OMG I need to try it!!

  • Rachael | Spache the Spatula
    Posted at 14:12h, 23 October Reply

    Maple-flavored peanut butter sounds outrageously good! I love PB&Co, but I never even knew they had that flavor!

    These cookies looks so perfectly chewy, and thin, and delicious! The chew factor AND the crisp factor together is a magical thing!
    Rachael | Spache the Spatula recently posted…Pumpkin Spice Latte MartiniMy Profile

  • CakePants
    Posted at 21:47h, 23 October Reply

    Wow…I love all parts of that recipe title: “maple” “peanut butter” and ESPECIALLY “toffee.” I will definitely have to share some of these cookies (my jeans too are telling me this, haha), because they look downright addictive!
    CakePants recently posted…Pumpkin Zucchini MuffinsMy Profile

  • Alexandra @ Confessions of a Bright-Eyed Baker
    Posted at 16:00h, 28 October Reply

    So many fun peanut butter flavors! I want some!! Right with you that a package of 5 kinds of peanut butter is the best kind of package haha 🙂
    Alexandra @ Confessions of a Bright-Eyed Baker recently posted…Almond Champagne Poached Pears with Almond Whipped CreamMy Profile

  • Abbie @ Needs Salt
    Posted at 18:47h, 31 October Reply

    I saw so many pictures on my instagram of lucky bloggers receiving these awesome little packages in the mail. Needless to say, I’m kind of jealous. Ahh, maple! I’m obsessed with it. These cookies look like the bomb. Could you make like Tiff’s Treats and deliver some to my door? (:
    Abbie @ Needs Salt recently posted…autumn things and life in a word (or 500.)My Profile

Post A Comment