05 Aug Herbed Fig & Goat Cheese Popsicles // Eff the Oven August

Herbed Fig & Goat Cheese Popsicles // butterlustblog.com

Last Friday the universe played a big, fat joke on me, y’all. Here I’ve been, planning out all kinds of no-bake recipes to share with you guys. Blabbing on about butt sweat and showing you pictures of dudes in thongs just to make a point about how hot Austin gets in the summer. And then August 1 rolls around and I’m all like EFF THE OVEN, HECK YEA!!!…but when I walk outside it’s the coolest day of the summer, yet. Record setting lows. Mother Nature, why ya gotta go and make me feel like a huge dweeb?

It’s okay, though. We’re still chilling and whipping and definitely not baking around here. Plus, starting Friday we’re hitting 100 degrees for at least 5 days in a row, probably forever. So ha! I win.

In case you missed Friday’s big kick-off, welcome to the second edition of Eff the Oven August!(!!!) I’m turning off the oven for the entire month. That’s right, we’re going 100% no bake. I started things off reaaal nice with this Coconut Cocao Nib Sorbet. We only used 3 ingredients. We talked about Cocao Nibs, the modern-ancient “superfood” with a tiny bit of an identity crisis. It was a party.

You know what else is a super food? Goat cheese. Not in the fancy marketing term, antioxidant-packed sense. More in the tangy, creamy, omg-pie-me-in-the-face-with-that-stuff super food sense. Ya follow?

Herbed Fig & Goat Cheese Popsicles // butterlustblog.comHerbed Fig & Goat Cheese Popsicles // butterlustblog.comHerbed Fig & Goat Cheese Popsicles // butterlustblog.com

I’ve been dying to put goat cheese in a dessert since I saw Elizabeth make these Goat Cheese Brownies back in June. And then Cynthia put a spin on a classic and posted these Blackberry Goat Cheese Thumbprint Cookies right about the time that I was in Upstate New York eating wild blackberries off of the bushes behind Steve’s family lake house, and I knew it was meant to be.

But I waited. I waited because I knew I wanted goat cheese in a no-bake, frozen dessert. And since I knew I was going to break up with my oven, I had to put all my frozen recipe ideas in my back pocket for like, a whole 3 weeks. Well, the time is finally here and I could not be more excited about these Herbed Fig & Goat Cheese Popsicles.

We talked about goat cheese. Now figs.

Steve is a fresh fig guy. And by ‘guy’, I mean thief. He’ll pluck them from from trees in people’s front yards or pop them in his mouth as we peruse the produce department at our local grocery. (H-E-B if you’re reading this, I’m sorry!!) Me? I can pass on fresh figs. They’re one of the most beautiful fruit to look at, but taste? Eh. I’d rather eat my way through half a bag of summer cherries.

Herbed Fig & Goat Cheese Popsicles // butterlustblog.com Herbed Fig & Goat Cheese Popsicles // butterlustblog.com

BUT when roasted with honey and paired with goat cheese, figs take on a whole new appeal. They’re sweet and peppery and completely irresistible. Add some brie and I die.

To quell Steve’s fig habit and satisfy my urge to pair them with all the cheese and honey, I made these guys. Homemade fig puree, tangy goat cheese, fresh thyme (from my tiny herb garden!!) and a splash of bourbon for good measure. They’re a grown-up popsicle, to be sure. I’d say you can omit the bourbon if serving to kids, but I have a hard time imaging a ten-year-old getting excited about a goat cheese popsicle. So leave the bourbon in, it helps keep the popsicles a little soft to the bite and because duh, bourbon.

A few notes about this recipe:

This recipe makes enough for 10 3-oz. popsicles, or the perfect amount for this NorPro Ice Pop mold. If you don’t have a popsicle mold you can use 3 oz. Dixie cups instead.

If you’re not a fan of figs, swap them for another fresh fruit of your choice. Cherries, strawberry, or even peaches would be great in this recipe.

To the same point, if you’re not a goat cheese person swap the goat cheese for another creamy dairy product — cream cheese, ricotta, mascarpone, greek yogurt…you catch my drift.

Stay cool! XO, Katie

Herbed Fig and Goat Cheese Popsicles // Eff the Oven August


  • 12 good-sized figs, quartered
  • 5 tbsp honey
  • 2 tbsp brown sugar
  • 2 tsp bourbon (optional)
  • 1 1/4 cups milk or half & half
  • 3 sprigs fresh thyme
  • 4 oz goat cheese
  • 1/2 tsp vanilla
  • 2 tsp bourbon (optional)


  • Combine figs, 2 tbsp honey and brown sugar in a medium saucepan over medium heat. Let cook, stirring occasionally for 15 minutes or until figs have lost a good amount of water and liquid in the bottom starts to become syrupy. Remove from heat and let cool for a few minutes then transfer to a food processor or blender. Add bourbon and pulse until a thick paste has formed -- leave as few or as many chunks as you'd like! Set aside.
  • In a medium saucepan, heat the milk over medium-low heat, until warm but not boiling. Add the thyme. Cover and steep over very low heat for 10 minutes. Remove or strain out the thyme and return to low heat.
  • Stir in the honey and vanilla and mix until combined. Add the goat cheese and whisk vigorously to emulsify. If your goat cheese remains lumpy, you may need to transfer the mixer to a food processor for some turbo-blending.
  • To assemble, scoop about a tablespoon of fig puree into each popsicle mold. Follow with your goat cheese mixture, filling each mold about half way. Divide the rest of the fig puree between each mold then top off with remaining goat cheese mixture.
  • Place on a flat surface in your freezer and freeze until firm, at least 4 - 6 hours.
  • cynthia
    Posted at 13:38h, 05 August Reply

    Oh my gosh. Oh my gosh. These look and sound SO. INCREDIBLE. The best ice cream I’ve ever made was a goat cheese & honey thing with poached pears — I’ve always wanted to try it with figs instead! These popsicles are perfection. And the photos are drop-dead gorgeous, too! (P.S. That trick with the Dixie cups is genius — I don’t have a popsicle mold, so you’ve just rocked my world in so many ways!)
    cynthia recently posted…Raspberry cardamom almond tarts // a guest post for Adventures in Cooking.My Profile

    • KWahlman
      Posted at 22:20h, 05 August Reply

      Aww thanks, lady! That goat cheese ice cream sounds to die for!!

  • Rachel
    Posted at 16:39h, 05 August Reply

    Ahhh I loved this post! Your writing is so effortless I love reading your posts. My dad is the same way-He is a fruit stealer. We once picked cherries at a house that was up for sale! Oopsie! ALso these popsicles look divine and I can not wait to try this! I think I will try with some herbed goat cheese I have in the fridge! Looking forward to more no-bake sweets!

  • Amanda - A Cookie Named Desire
    Posted at 16:10h, 06 August Reply

    Yum! My mom is a fruit stealer and is starting to teach my daughter her ways. I haven’t really used goat’s cheese in a sweet application, but haven’t really come up with anything yet. I really want to make these though.
    Amanda – A Cookie Named Desire recently posted…Raspberry Peach Clafoutis Recipe with Caramelized Sugar CrustMy Profile

    • KWahlman
      Posted at 16:44h, 06 August Reply

      I must admit, I’m relieved to hear that fruit stealing is so common. Maybe it’ll save me some money on therapy for Steve 🙂 Goat cheese is good in all applications!

  • Cassidy Re
    Posted at 22:02h, 10 August Reply

    Oh my gosh!!!!! These sound so finger lickin’ good. I just might have to make these, i’m only afraid they wont turn out as beautiful as these! I love making ice cream and these popsicle’s are the perfect next thing to try.
    Cassidy Re recently posted…Home Sweet Home: Part 1My Profile

    • KWahlman
      Posted at 09:29h, 11 August Reply

      Making them pretty is the easiest part because you just get to dump the ingredients into the popsicle mold. You should totally do it!!

  • Rachel
    Posted at 15:24h, 12 August Reply

    Katie I made these! Oh my that fig puree is heaven! I could eat it by the spoonful. The only problem I had was the consistency of the milk/goat cheese mixture. It got wierdly lumpy-which I think might have been from the milk being too hot. The flavors combined though were delicious! A nice summer treat! Just wanted to let you know 🙂 -Rachel
    Rachel recently posted…Melons 101: Tips and RecipesMy Profile

    • KWahlman
      Posted at 10:05h, 13 August Reply

      So happy to hear you tried them, Rachel! Sorry your goat cheese got lumpy 🙁 I did have to whisk mine pretty vigorously to get it to blend properly. Perhaps emulsifying in a food processor is the key?

  • Buttermilk Panna Cotta with Strawberry Crumble Topping // Eff the Oven August - Butterlust
    Posted at 10:40h, 29 August Reply

    […] zone. And I liked it. I made several kinds of dessert never seen before on Butterlust — from these popsicles to this icebox cake to these quinoa puddings. All of these having been on the to-make list for some […]

Post A Comment